Well, I’ve given out this address to a few close friends that I thought wouldn’t tease me about it too much. I figure the only person that probably looks at it is Mac, since he has it on RSS. I haven’t even given the address to my wife, because despite the fact that she is very supportive, she thinks I bite off more than I can chew too often. So, today I want to discuss Supplements. Specifically, I want to discuss the 2-5 Rule of thumb. Since most of my friends have heard me talk about my 2-5 Rule of Health supplements, I’m sure most are going to stop reading right about now.
A long time ago I started preaching the 2-5 Rule to friends and anyone who would listen. It goes this way: Any health supplement, no matter how good, can only help you meet your health goal by a maximum of 2%. No matter how many health supplements you take, combined they can only help you reach your health goal by 5%. Hence, the 2-5 rule. Notice I state this in no uncertain terms, “any health supplement, no matter how good.” Even Steroids (I’ll talk more about this later on since it seems appropriate with the hearings going on) and medically prescribed drugs.
I’m sure a lot of you (if there were a lot of people reading this) would be saying “no way!” But stay with me, this is a journey, not a destination. Let’s look at the normal health supplements, like creatine. Supposedly (and if you want information about what creatine is I suggest: http://www.building-muscle101.com/article2.html), it helps muscle recovery, helps strength gains and also helps endurance athletes. If you believe some people in the “supplement” community, it’s also what Jesus used to allow him to walk on water. No matter how much creatine you take though, if you don’t work out, it don’t do jack! The only way it does anything is by putting in the time and sweat.
This seems obvious when you think about a weight lifting supplement, but what about steroids and medically prescribed weight loss drugs. Let’s start with the later, because it will clarify the former. Medically prescribed weight loss drugs, which from here on out will be referred to as THE PILL (insert dramatic music). I’m over weight. I go to the doctor, tell him I’ve tried every diet, I’ve tried every exercise, I’ve even tried the ab-roller thingie I saw on TV (funny story, my doctor actually used the ab-roller until his back went out on him while doing it). “Doctor, please help me!” I say frantically. “Ok, over-weight person, we have a fix for this, it’s called THE PILL. You take THE PILL every day, before each meal, for the rest of your life and THE PILL, will keep you healthy!”. Sounds good! But truthfully, while some doctors might say that, most would truthfully say it will keep your weight low, because it probably won’t help your health.
This person (I can’t do the first person thing for too long) will be on THE PILL for the rest of their life, or as long as they want to keep their weight down. They’ll deal with the side-effects (have you ever taken a med that didn’t have a side effect) because they want to keep their weight down. So you say this doesn’t meet the 2-5 Rule. And I would agree with you if the fitness goal was strictly to keep your weight down. But a fitness goal is generally multi-leveled. Your primary goal might be to keep your weight off so you look good. The assumption is you want to keep the weight off because you want to enjoy a better quality of life. You want to be healthier. You want to live longer and enjoy the years that you have left. You want to improve yourself. If you just want to keep your weight low, I suggest you get some help, because that’s the path that often leads to eating disorders. The 2-5 rule (which I used to think doesn’t work in these cases) still applies because it’s all about the why! So by taking THE PILL your weight will stay down, but you haven’t changed your eating path. So the same crap is going into your body (maybe less depending on the pill). Your quality of life might actually go down because of any side effects and most importantly you haven’t improved your WILL, you’ve weakened it. This sounds to me like THE PILL gives you less than 2%. IMHO the will is possibly the most important ingredient. The will.
In my dojo, it’s talked about a lot. Strengthen the will. Every time you follow through to a promise to yourself, you strengthen it. Every time you give up on a promise, you weaken it. It’s internal, but it’s the important part of any fitness goal. This is the staying power. The stronger you build the will, the longer you can get the salad instead of the fried Twinkies. The more often you get up at 3:30 in the morning, because you want to get that workout in. It’s long lasting too, if you did get the fried twinkies, it’s the thing that gets you back on the wagon. Supplements are in truth a weakness to many, because you get dependent on them doing some of the work. Even if you found 10 supplements that together make everything easy, it means you missed out on the opportunity and the life-building experience of doing it the hard way. You are back down to 5%.
Let’s talk steroids, since that is all over the news. A friend of mine took a set of steroids back in college. He told me about the experience. He told me about the side-effects (despite only taking half the dosage his “supplier” recommended). He told me in detail about all the negative things that happened to him, whether it was almost getting caught with them in his gym bag, to feeling really crappy about “cheating” and even the loss of sleep that was caused by the steroid. He said one other thing that I have to bring up. He said they worked. He never made gains in strength and size so quick. He couldn’t believe the size of his arms and chest. It really made the difference. I’m sure you know the type of damage that they cause as well, if not see someone who knows more than me, I know just enough biology to sound like I know what I’m talking about, which makes me dangerous. Still, it did what it promised to do. Steroids promise to increase your size and strength; they fulfill their promise. You are prone to injury because of the speed of the gains and supposedly because of the damage that it does to your cartilage and muscles. On top of that, when you stop taking them, you lose the gains.
If you were to tell me that a kid was taking steroids because he wanted more strength gains, I would say, he’s an idiot, but go ahead. Natural selection. He’s losing his opportunity to build his will through hard work by taking a short cut. IMHO, because of the speed and visibility of the gains, it’s much worse then something like creatine. If you were to tell me that an athelete was taking steroids so that he could make it to the pros. I would say, he’s an idiot; he’s squandering any chance he gets at being healthy; he’s cheating and encouraging (subtly) other people to cheat; he’s wasting and cheapening the talent that he does have; he’s spoiling the sport and all those who play it for fun; I can understand the motivation. Now, if you were to tell me a professional athlete in the prime of his career was taking steroids to improve his performance, I would say that he will never enjoy a moment of his career after that, and shouldn’t. When I was testing for my second yellow sash, during one period where we were “staying warm” (actually it’s a torture they use on you) I was doing pushups along with the other guys. I slowed down and stopped because I mentally couldn’t push myself harder. To this day, I still feel guilty for that. I know physically I could have done more, but mentally I gave up. It was only one of the many minor concessions I made during the test. I could list others because I still feel my achievement was cheapened, albeit slightly, by the concessions. I can’t imagine a pro-athlete, who gets paid for what most people do for fun, can look themselves in the face, or their children’s faces, or their fan’s faces. Ever.